Stability of Benzene — Question 5

Section 18-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 4139–4140

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Analyze the electronic problem in an ideal square four-electron ring

Use the ideal regular four-site model with levels −2,0,0,+2-2,0,0,+2 in units of |β||\beta|. Place four pi electrons using the independent-electron model.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. How many electrons fit in the lowest bonding orbital?

  2. Where must the remaining electrons go?

  3. Why does this fail to give the same closed bonding shell as benzene?

Question 5 - Solution

Analyze the electronic problem in an ideal square four-electron ring

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Two electrons fit in the lowest bonding orbital.

(b)

The other two enter the degenerate nonbonding pair, one in each under the elementary Hund-rule filling model.

(c)

The bonding level alone cannot accommodate all four electrons. The ideal square is electronically unstable; real cyclobutadiene distorts, so the diagram is not its complete actual-state description.