Determining the Directing Effects of a Substituent — Question 6

Section 19-10 · Organic Chemistry pages 4421–4422

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Check a proposed meta-donor resonance map

A student claims direct donor lone-pair donation stabilizes this arenium ion exactly as in para attack.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Does the given contributor set place a cation at C1?

  2. Can a C1-to-donor pi bond be added without changing the rest of the electron bookkeeping?

  3. What positional conclusion follows in the ordinary donor model?

Question 6 - Solution

Check a proposed meta-donor resonance map

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

No. The charge placements omit C1.

(b)

No. A valid contributor must conserve electrons and valence; simply adding a donor double bond is not legitimate.

(c)

Ortho/para ions gain the special donor-stabilized contributor that this meta ion lacks.