Identifying the Mechanism of an Aromatic Substitution Reaction — Question 6

Section 19-15 · Organic Chemistry pages 4521–4522

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Read intermediate charge before naming the mechanism

Treat the first Nu as an anion that becomes neutral upon bonding; counterions are omitted.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which row is characteristic of ordinary EAS?

  2. Which row is characteristic of classical SNAr addition?

  3. Why does negative charge alone not distinguish the last two pathways?

Question 6 - Solution

Read intermediate charge before naming the mechanism

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

The first row describes a cationic arenium ion formed by electrophilic capture.

(b)

The second row describes an anionic sigma adduct before leaving-group elimination.

(c)

Both can contain anionic intermediates; one retains the leaving group at a tetrahedral carbon, while the aryne-addition anion forms after the leaving group is gone.