Friedel-Crafts Alkylation — Question 2

Section 19-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 4313–4314

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Follow a hydride shift rather than moving a methyl label

Use a simplified primary propyl-cation drawing to analyze the rearrangement risk; a free long-lived primary cation is not assumed.

Formal cation before rearrangement
  1. Which adjacent hydride migration gives a more stable cation?

  2. Where does the positive charge end up?

  3. Which alkylbenzene can result after ring capture?

Question 2 - Solution

Follow a hydride shift rather than moving a methyl label

Secondary cation

(a)

A hydride shifts from C2 to terminal C1 with its electron pair.

(b)

The positive charge moves to C2, giving the secondary isopropyl cation.

(c)

Capture gives isopropylbenzene rather than a reliably unrearranged n-propyl product.