Friedel-Crafts Acylation — Question 3

Section 19-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 4335–4336

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Compare acylation with an alkyl rearrangement risk

Compare ordinary acylium behavior with a rearrangement-prone primary alkyl electrophile.

A: acyl electrophile
B: formal primary alkyl cation
  1. Which is resonance stabilized by oxygen?

  2. Which strategy normally preserves the acyl carbon skeleton in Friedel–Crafts capture?

  3. Why is treating A like an unconjugated primary alkyl cation misleading?

Question 3 - Solution

Compare acylation with an alkyl rearrangement risk

A: acyl electrophile
B: formal primary alkyl cation

(a)

A is stabilized by oxygen lone-pair donation into the acyl carbon center.

(b)

Acylation normally preserves the acyl skeleton without the usual alkyl-carbocation rearrangement.

(c)

It ignores the distinctive resonance stabilization and bonding of an acylium ion.