Assessing Relative Importance of Resonance Structures — Question 2

Section 2-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 473–474

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

An oxygen plus sign can accompany the better contributor

The first O has two pairs; the second has one. Both structures have total charge +1.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.↔\longleftrightarrowMolecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.

  1. Compare the carbon octets.

  2. Which contributor is more important under the octet criterion?

  3. Why does simply avoiding positive charge on electronegative O give the wrong priority here?

Question 2 - Solution

An oxygen plus sign can accompany the better contributor

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.↔\longleftrightarrowMolecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.

(a)

The first terminal carbon has six electrons. In the second, all C and O atoms have octets.

(b)

The oxonium contributor with C=O and O+ is more important because it completes the carbon octet.

(c)

Electronegativity is considered after this major octet distinction. A full octet can outweigh the preference against positive charge on O.