Carbon Atoms with Formal Charges — Question 3

Section 2-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 335–336

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

A double bond counts twice

The positively charged carbon bears exactly the one H written; it has no nonbonding electrons.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Vinyl cation
  1. Sum the bond orders at the charged carbon.

  2. Verify the charge by assigning one electron per bond order to carbon.

  3. Explain why adding an unwritten H would change the species.

Question 3 - Solution

A double bond counts twice

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Vinyl cation

(a)

The C=C contributes two and the C–H contributes one, for a bond-order sum of three.

(b)

The carbon owns three electrons, so its formal charge is 4−3=+14-3=+1; its surrounding count is six.

(c)

Adding H would raise the bond-order sum to four and yield neutral ethene. Hydrogens must satisfy the explicitly stated charge and electron count, not erase them.