Formal Charges in Resonance Structures — Question 8

Section 2-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 445–446

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Diagnose a tempting but invalid nitro drawing

A student tries to eliminate all nitro formal charges by drawing two N=O bonds and one N–C bond.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Proposed neutral structure; audit it
  1. Count electrons around N.

  2. Explain why this is unacceptable for ordinary second-row N.

  3. Repair the drawing while keeping both O atoms attached.

Question 8 - Solution

Diagnose a tempting but invalid nitro drawing

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Valid nitro contributor

(a)

N has five bond orders, placing ten electrons around it.

(b)

Ordinary second-row nitrogen cannot expand its octet to accommodate this proposal. Removing charge labels does not repair excessive valence.

(c)

Replace one N=O with N–O, put +1 on N and -1 on the singly bonded O. Give that O three pairs and the other O two.