Introduction to Aldehydes and Ketones — Question 8

Section 20-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 4545–4546

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Compare formal oxidation states at two carbonyl carbons

Assign +1 per bond from carbon to O, -1 per bond from carbon to H, and zero for C–C bonds.

A: ethanal
B: propanone
  1. Find the carbonyl-carbon oxidation state in A.

  2. Find it in B.

  3. Why is oxidation state not the same as formal charge?

Question 8 - Solution

Compare formal oxidation states at two carbonyl carbons

A: ethanal
B: propanone

(a)

A has +2 from C=O and -1 from C–H, giving +1.

(b)

B has +2 from C=O and no C–H bond at that carbon, giving +2.

(c)

Oxidation state assigns bonding electrons by electronegativity; formal charge splits bonding electrons equally. Both neutral carbonyl carbons have formal charge zero.