Introduction to Carboxylic Acids — Question 9

Section 21-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 4807–4808

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Distinguish resonance from movement of a proton

The two contributors have identical atom positions and connectivity.

Contributor A
Contributor B
  1. Which electrons change placement?

  2. Does an oxygen atom or proton move between contributors?

  3. What does the resonance hybrid imply about the two C–O bonds in a symmetric environment?

Question 9 - Solution

Distinguish resonance from movement of a proton

Contributor A
Contributor B

(a)

A lone pair forms one C=O pi bond while the other pi pair becomes a lone pair.

(b)

No nuclei move. These are resonance contributors, not separate proton-transfer products.

(c)

The two C–O bonds are equivalent in the symmetric carboxylate environment, with bond order intermediate between one and two.