Introduction to Alpha Carbon Chemistry - Enols and Enolates — Question 3

Section 22-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 5095–5096

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Separate resonance contributors from different molecules

The two drawings represent an acetone-derived anion.

Carbon contributor
Oxygen contributor

Resonance contributors of one ion; no atoms move.

  1. What moves between these drawings?

  2. Where is the net negative charge in each contributor?

  3. Why are the drawings not a tautomeric equilibrium?

Question 3 - Solution

Separate resonance contributors from different molecules

Carbon contributor
Oxygen contributor

Resonance contributors of one ion; no atoms move.

(a)

Only electron placement changes; nuclei and sigma connectivity remain fixed.

(b)

The carbon contributor places charge on the alpha carbon; the oxygen contributor places it on oxygen. Each has net charge -1.

(c)

Tautomers differ in proton placement and bonding. These are contributors to one delocalized ion.