Introduction to Alpha Carbon Chemistry - Enols and Enolates — Question 8

Section 22-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 5105–5106

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Use supplied barriers rather than equating speed with stability

Treat all tabulated energies as Gibbs free energies relative to the same reference state. Assume comparable prefactors; A and B interconvert only under a separate equilibration protocol.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which product forms faster initially?

  2. Which is favored after full equilibration under the supplied energy model?

  3. What experimental distinction must be preserved when naming kinetic and thermodynamic products?

Question 8 - Solution

Use supplied barriers rather than equating speed with stability

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

A has the lower activation barrier and forms faster initially.

(b)

B has lower product energy and is favored at equilibrium in the stated model.

(c)

Rapid trapping before equilibration probes kinetic control; reversible equilibration probes thermodynamic control.