Alpha Halogenation of Enols and Enolates — Question 6

Section 22-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 5121–5122

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Distinguish a methyl ketone from other carbonyl compounds

Compare direct haloform cleavage of these ketones under the same standard excess halogen/base conditions.

A
B
  1. Which contains the required COCH3 unit?

  2. Why does A fail the direct methyl-ketone criterion?

  3. Would a positive iodoform test establish a unique molecular identity?

Question 6 - Solution

Distinguish a methyl ketone from other carbonyl compounds

A
B

(a)

B, butan-2-one, contains COCH3.

(b)

A is pentan-3-one; both carbonyl substituents are ethyl, so neither is a directly attached methyl group.

(c)

No. Many methyl ketones, and alcohols oxidizable to them under the test conditions, can give a positive result.