Introduction to Amines — Question 10

Section 23-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 5249–5250

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Distinguish a protonated tertiary amine from a quaternary ion

Both cations have four nitrogen bonds.

A
B
  1. Which can give a neutral amine by losing an N-bound proton?

  2. Which has four carbon groups on nitrogen?

  3. Why does ordinary deprotonation not neutralize B in the same way?

Question 10 - Solution

Distinguish a protonated tertiary amine from a quaternary ion

A
B

(a)

A loses its N–H proton to regenerate trimethylamine.

(b)

B is tetramethylammonium, a quaternary ammonium ion.

(c)

B has no N–H proton; neutralization cannot occur by simply removing one from nitrogen.