Introduction to Carbohydrates — Question 2

Section 24-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 5493–5494

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Test the historical hydrate-of-carbon formula

Glucose and acetic acid both have a 1:2:1 C:H:O atom ratio.

C6H12O6 ; C2H4O2\text{C6H12O6 ; C2H4O2}

  1. Write the empirical formula shared by both.

  2. Does the ratio alone establish that acetic acid is a carbohydrate?

  3. What structural information is missing?

Question 2 - Solution

Test the historical hydrate-of-carbon formula

C6H12O6 ; C2H4O2\text{C6H12O6 ; C2H4O2}

(a)

Both have empirical formula CH2O.

(b)

No. An empirical ratio does not identify a functional-group class.

(c)

Connectivity and functional groups are needed; acetic acid is a carboxylic acid rather than a polyhydroxy aldehyde or ketone.