Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Compare energy use on an equal recovered-product basis
The outputs meet the same stated product requirement. The figures include only the specified processing boundary and are illustrative.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate processing energy per kg of usable output for A.
Calculate it for B and identify the lower value.
Why is this calculation insufficient for a complete environmental ranking?
Question 10 - Solution
Compare energy use on an equal recovered-product basis
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
A uses 1.5/0.80 = 1.875 MJ per kg of usable output.
(b)
B uses 5.0/0.90 = 5.56 MJ per kg of usable output, approximately. A has the lower value within the stated boundary.
(c)
A full comparison also requires relevant energy sources, transport, reagents, emissions, waste handling and consistent life-cycle boundaries. One processing-energy metric is insufficient.