Flow of Electron Density: Curved Arrow Notation — Question 3

Section 3-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 535–536

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

A negative sign is not the arrow tail

Hydroxide removes the methanol O–H proton. The donor pair on hydroxide is explicitly shown above O.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Place the two arrows at actual electron sources.

  2. How do the two oxygen formal charges change?

  3. Why is an arrow drawn from a floating minus sign less precise than one drawn from a lone pair?

Question 3 - Solution

A negative sign is not the arrow tail

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

OH- + CH3OH <=> H2O + CH3O-\text{OH- + CH3OH <=> H2O + CH3O-}

(a)

Start at the hydroxide pair and end at the methanol H; start the methanol O–H bond arrow on that bond and end on its O.

(b)

Hydroxide O goes from -1 to 0 in water. Methanol O goes from 0 to -1 in methoxide.

(c)

The minus sign reports an electron-ownership imbalance; it is not itself a specific pair. The drawn pair identifies the electrons used.