Flow of Electron Density: Curved Arrow Notation — Question 9

Section 3-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 547–548

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Proton transfer changes nuclear attachment; resonance does not

A base converts the left species to the right by accepting its O–H proton.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Acetic acid
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Acetate contributor
  1. Is a resonance double-headed arrow appropriate between these two species?

  2. Describe the necessary pair movements for the proton transfer.

  3. What additional molecule must appear on the product side if the base is NH3?

Question 9 - Solution

Proton transfer changes nuclear attachment; resonance does not

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

CH3CO2H + NH3 <=> CH3CO2- + NH4+\text{CH3CO2H + NH3 <=> CH3CO2- + NH4+}

(a)

No. A proton changes its attachment and the isolated acid species changes composition and charge. These are not two resonance contributors.

(b)

The base pair goes to the O–H hydrogen; the O–H bond pair goes to its oxygen.

(c)

must appear. Omitting it would conceal where the proton and compensating positive charge went.