Position of Equilibrium and Choice of Reagents — Question 9

Section 3-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 607–608

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Product removal shifts composition without rewriting pKa

Consider the formal proton-transfer reaction of an alcohol with hydride. A spectator counterion is omitted. Compare a closed system with one from which H2 is removed.

ROH + H- <=> RO- + H2\text{ROH + H- <=> RO- + H2}

  1. Identify the acid, base and new H–H bond.

  2. Explain how removing H2 affects the reaction quotient.

  3. Does removal alter the intrinsic equilibrium constant at fixed temperature?

Question 9 - Solution

Product removal shifts composition without rewriting pKa

ROH + H- <=> RO- + H2\text{ROH + H- <=> RO- + H2}

(a)

ROH donates H+ and hydride accepts it. The hydride pair forms the H–H bond; the O–H pair remains on O.

(b)

Lowering the hydrogen activity or fugacity lowers Q and favors further product formation toward equilibrium.

(c)

No. Product removal changes conditions represented in Q, not the fixed-temperature intrinsic K. Gas removal and pKa comparison are distinct contributions to the practical outcome.