Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Product removal shifts composition without rewriting pKa
Consider the formal proton-transfer reaction of an alcohol with hydride. A spectator counterion is omitted. Compare a closed system with one from which H2 is removed.
Identify the acid, base and new H–H bond.
Explain how removing H2 affects the reaction quotient.
Does removal alter the intrinsic equilibrium constant at fixed temperature?
Question 9 - Solution
Product removal shifts composition without rewriting pKa
(a)
ROH donates H+ and hydride accepts it. The hydride pair forms the H–H bond; the O–H pair remains on O.
(b)
Lowering the hydrogen activity or fugacity lowers Q and favors further product formation toward equilibrium.
(c)
No. Product removal changes conditions represented in Q, not the fixed-temperature intrinsic K. Gas removal and pKa comparison are distinct contributions to the practical outcome.