Show solutionHide solution
Question 1
Equal strong-acid pH values can conceal different acids
Compare ideal dilute 0.0100 M solutions of HCl and HBr in water. Treat each as fully ionized and neglect water autoionization.
Predict the hydronium concentration and pH of each.
Which acid species dominates the proton-donating behavior in both solutions?
Does the equal pH prove identical acid strengths in every solvent?
Question 1 - Solution
Equal strong-acid pH values can conceal different acids
(a)
Each has approximately 0.0100 M hydronium and pH 2.00.
(b)
The common solvated proton species, represented as , dominates. Water converts both stronger acids into its conjugate acid.
(c)
No. This is solvent leveling. Another medium can distinguish their proton-transfer equilibria; equality in this dilute aqueous test is not a universal identity.