Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Dielectric response and hydrogen bonding are different properties
The matched dielectric constants describe similar bulk electrostatic screening in this comparison. No other solvent data are supplied.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Can the solvents still differ in specific anion solvation?
Which listed feature allows conventional O–H hydrogen-bond donation to an anion?
Can these data alone establish the pKa of an acid in either solvent?
Question 8 - Solution
Dielectric response and hydrogen bonding are different properties
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
Yes. Equal bulk dielectric constants do not imply identical local molecular interactions.
(b)
The O–H groups in P supply that donor interaction; Q lacks the listed protic donors.
(c)
No. Full acid/base equilibria depend on differential solvation, standard states and other properties. A dielectric constant alone is not a pKa scale.