Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Distinguish hydrogen-bond solvation from completed proton transfer
The diagram represents one hydrogen-bonded contact between alkoxide and water, not a completed reaction.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Where is the indicated H covalently attached in this drawing?
What bond changes would distinguish full transfer to the alkoxide?
Does one solvation contact by itself establish the equilibrium product distribution?
Question 10 - Solution
Distinguish hydrogen-bond solvation from completed proton transfer
(a)
It remains attached to the water oxygen by the solid O–H bond.
(b)
A new RO–H covalent bond would form and the old water O–H bond would break, giving ROH and hydroxide.
(c)
No. A solvation contact is an interaction within the starting ensemble. Product fractions require the full equilibrium free-energy and mass-balance information.