Counterions — Question 6

Section 3-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 661–662

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Do not confuse a hydride anion with a sodium atom

This is formal ionic bookkeeping for an alcohol reacting with sodium hydride; it is not a detailed model of the solid surface.

Na+ + H- + ROH -> Na+ + RO- + H2\text{Na+ + H- + ROH -> Na+ + RO- + H2}

  1. Which species accepts the alcohol proton?

  2. What happens to the hydride electron pair?

  3. Where is the counterion in the product bookkeeping?

Question 6 - Solution

Do not confuse a hydride anion with a sodium atom

Na+ + H- + ROH -> Na+ + RO- + H2\text{Na+ + H- + ROH -> Na+ + RO- + H2}

(a)

Hydride, H-, accepts H+.

(b)

Its pair becomes the H–H bonding pair. The alcohol O–H pair stays on O, making alkoxide.

(c)

Na+ remains the counterion to RO-. Sodium does not need to become neutral or receive the proton to balance the equation.