Lewis Acids and Bases — Question 4

Section 3-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 677–678

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Connect the Lewis and proton-transfer descriptions

Analyze the elementary bonding step that forms ammonium from ammonia and a proton.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Ammonia
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Proton
  1. Identify the Lewis acid and Lewis base.

  2. Identify the proton acceptor in the proton-transfer description.

  3. Does the Lewis definition require every acid to contain a transferable H?

Question 4 - Solution

Connect the Lewis and proton-transfer descriptions

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Ammonium

(a)

H+ accepts an electron pair and is the Lewis acid; NH3 donates its pair and is the Lewis base.

(b)

NH3 is also the proton acceptor, hence a base in the proton-transfer definition.

(c)

No. Electron-pair acceptors such as BF3 contain no transferable H. The Lewis framework includes bonding events beyond proton transfer.