Relative Stability of Isomeric Alkanes — Question 4

Section 4-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 757–758

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Do not compare raw combustion heats across formulas

A student calls the second compound less stable because it releases more heat per mole.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Why is the common-products argument unavailable?

  2. Calculate the heat-release magnitude per mole of carbon for each.

  3. Does equality of that normalized quantity prove equal molecular stability?

Question 4 - Solution

Do not compare raw combustion heats across formulas

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

The formulas differ, so their balanced reactions consume different oxygen amounts and form different product amounts.

(b)

Both give 700700 kJ per mole of carbon in this supplied example.

(c)

No. The normalization describes energy per carbon, not an isomerization enthalpy or an absolute stability ranking.