Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Diagnose the planar-pentagon shortcut
A regular planar pentagon has interior angles of 108 degrees.
| Cyclopentane connectivity |
Why might an angle-only argument predict very low strain?
What strain source does that argument omit?
Why can an envelope-like nonplanar conformation be preferred?
Question 5 - Solution
Diagnose the planar-pentagon shortcut
| Cyclopentane connectivity |
(a)
is close to the ideal tetrahedral angle.
(b)
The planar arrangement has substantial eclipsing-related torsional strain.
(c)
Puckering reduces some eclipsing while retaining reasonable bond angles. Near-ideal polygon angles do not guarantee the lowest total energy.