Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Reject a ring-size-only stability ranking
A student claims every increase in ring size must decrease strain because the ring becomes less sharply bent.
| Six-membered ring |
| Eight-membered ring |
What is wrong with treating each ring as a regular planar polygon?
Name two strain contributions besides bond-angle distortion.
What evidence is needed for a reliable comparison of these actual rings?
Question 10 - Solution
Reject a ring-size-only stability ranking
| Six-membered ring |
| Eight-membered ring |
(a)
Flexible rings adopt nonplanar conformations, so polygon angles do not specify their real local geometries.
(b)
Torsional strain and nonbonded crowding, including transannular interactions across a ring, can contribute.
(c)
Use actual conformational geometry and consistent thermochemical data or a stated energy model. Ring size alone does not establish a monotonic strain ranking.