Symmetry and Chirality — Question 7

Section 5-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 1103–1104

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Do not mistake the page for a molecular mirror plane

A student argues that the page is a symmetry plane because the drawing is printed on flat paper.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. What would reflection through the page do to the solid-wedge F bond?

  2. Is there an identical F group in the corresponding reflected position?

  3. Why is the flatness of the drawing irrelevant to the chirality test?

Question 7 - Solution

Do not mistake the page for a molecular mirror plane

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

It would send the toward-reader F group to an away-reader position with the same in-page coordinates.

(b)

No. The structure has only one F group, at a different depth from its reflected location.

(c)

The drawing encodes a three-dimensional arrangement. Molecular symmetry must preserve atom identities and all spatial coordinates, including wedge/hash depth.