Symmetry and Chirality — Question 9

Section 5-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 1107–1108

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Use the full symmetry criterion rather than a mirror-plane-only shortcut

The coordinate mapping is a stipulated property of the complete model, including isotope identities.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which symmetry element is present?

  2. Can such a rigid arrangement be chiral?

  3. Why is failure to find a mirror plane alone not a general proof of chirality?

Question 9 - Solution

Use the full symmetry criterion rather than a mirror-plane-only shortcut

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

A center of inversion is present.

(b)

No. Inversion is an improper symmetry operation; its presence makes the arrangement achiral.

(c)

Other improper symmetry operations can also make an object achiral. A full chirality argument must exclude all relevant improper symmetries, not only obvious mirror planes.