Fischer Projections — Question 8

Section 5-7 · Organic Chemistry pages 1125–1126

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Find identical meso drawings among reflected Fischer projections

The two terminal CO2H groups are identical.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Assign the two configuration pairs.

  2. What allowed Fischer operation superimposes A on B?

  3. Are these distinct enantiomers?

Question 8 - Solution

Find identical meso drawings among reflected Fischer projections

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

A is (2R,3S) and B is (2S,3R) with top-to-bottom numbering.

(b)

A 180-degree in-page rotation of A gives B because the terminal groups are identical.

(c)

No. They are the same meso tartaric acid stereoisomer. Reflection alone does not guarantee a distinct enantiomer when the mirror image is superimposable.