Resolution of Enantiomers — Question 3

Section 5-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 1155–1156

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Expose the symmetry restored by a racemic resolving agent

A racemic acid HAR/HASHA_R/HA_S is mixed with a racemic, configurationally stable base BR/BSB_R/B_S. The labels identify retained carbon configurations. Consider all four possible 1:1 salt combinations.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the two mirror-related salt pairs.

  2. Why is the simple two-diastereomer argument for an enantiopure resolving agent insufficient here?

  3. Does this prove that no conceivable crystallization-based resolution is possible?

Question 3 - Solution

Expose the symmetry restored by a racemic resolving agent

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

AR−BHR+A_R^-BH_R^+ and AS−BHS+A_S^-BH_S^+ form one mirror pair; AR−BHS+A_R^-BH_S^+ and AS−BHR+A_S^-BH_R^+ form the other.

(b)

Both resolving-agent configurations are present, so each combination has its mirror counterpart. The protocol has no imposed single-handed resolving-agent bias.

(c)

No. Special crystallization behavior or an additional chiral influence may permit other strategies. The four-combination analysis invalidates the proposed simple enantiopure-agent rationale; it is not a universal impossibility proof.