Enthalpy — Question 4

Section 6-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 1177–1178

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Reject the claim that bond breaking releases energy

The supplied enthalpy for this homolytic dissociation is +439 kJ per mole.

CH4(g) -> CH3^.(g) + H^.(g)\text{CH4(g) -> CH3^{.}(g) + H^{.}(g)}

  1. Is the indicated bond-breaking step endothermic or exothermic?

  2. What is the enthalpy of the exact reverse association?

  3. How can an overall reaction that breaks bonds still be exothermic?

Question 4 - Solution

Reject the claim that bond breaking releases energy

CH4(g) -> CH3^.(g) + H^.(g)\text{CH4(g) -> CH3^{.}(g) + H^{.}(g)}

(a)

It is endothermic: separation into these gas-phase radicals requires energy.

(b)

The reverse association has delta H = -439 kJ per mole.

(c)

The overall reaction may form bonds that release more energy than is required to break the initial bonds. Count both contributions; breaking alone is not the source of the release.