Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Compare two migrations from the same adjacent donor carbon
Compare transfer of the explicit C3–H bond with transfer of the C3–C5 methyl bond to C2. Keep atom labels fixed.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Where does the positive charge end up in each case?
Classify C3 in each resulting cation.
What can the simple alkyl-stability comparison suggest, and what can it not prove?
Question 4 - Solution
Compare two migrations from the same adjacent donor carbon
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
In both cases, the positive charge ends at C3, which donates the migrating bond pair.
(b)
After hydride shift C3 remains attached to three carbons and is tertiary. After methyl shift it has two carbon neighbors and H, so it is secondary.
(c)
The hydride-shift product is more stabilized in the simple comparable alkyl model. This alone does not establish an exact product ratio or a universal rule that hydride always migrates first.