Carbocation Rearrangements — Question 8

Section 6-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 1385–1386

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Test whether a proposed shift improves a simple alkyl cation

Formally transfer one H from an adjacent methyl group to the central cationic carbon. Compare ordinary unconjugated alkyl cations under otherwise comparable conditions.

Initial tert-butyl cation
  1. Draw the resulting carbon framework and charge location.

  2. Classify the initial and resulting cations.

  3. Is rearrangement automatically expected merely because a carbocation exists?

Question 8 - Solution

Test whether a proposed shift improves a simple alkyl cation

Formal hydride-shift product

(a)

The central carbon becomes CH; the methyl that donated H becomes CH2 positive. The C–C skeleton remains the same.

(b)

The initial center is tertiary; the new CH2 positive center is primary.

(c)

No. This shift worsens the simple alkyl-cation stability ranking, so it is not a favorable stabilization rationale. Capture or other pathways may compete; existence of a cation does not require rearrangement.