Nucleophiles and Electrophiles — Question 2

Section 6-7 · Organic Chemistry pages 1293–1294

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Locate both kinds of reactive site in a carbonyl group

Consider the same neutral molecule reacting either with an electron-pair donor or with a proton donor.

Formaldehyde
  1. Which atom is the usual electrophilic site for nucleophilic addition?

  2. Which atom can donate a lone pair to a proton?

  3. Must the carbon carry a formal positive charge to be electrophilic?

Question 2 - Solution

Locate both kinds of reactive site in a carbonyl group

Formaldehyde

(a)

The carbonyl carbon is the electrophilic addition site because the C=O bond is polarized toward oxygen.

(b)

Oxygen can donate a lone pair to an acidic proton. Its role in protonation is nucleophilic/basic.

(c)

No. The carbon is formally neutral in this Lewis structure but partially electron-deficient. Formal and partial charges are different concepts.