Nucleophiles and Electrophiles — Question 5

Section 6-7 · Organic Chemistry pages 1299–1300

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Predict the charge after a neutral water molecule donates

Analyze the formal bond-forming event between these depicted species; this is a local electron-accounting model, not a claim that a free methyl cation persists in water.

Water
Methyl cation
  1. Which atom donates, and where does its pair go?

  2. Draw the immediate oxygen-containing product without a later proton transfer.

  3. Count oxygen bonds, lone pairs and formal charge.

Question 5 - Solution

Predict the charge after a neutral water molecule donates

Immediate adduct

(a)

Water oxygen donates one pair to the electron-deficient carbon, forming O–C.

(b)

The immediate product is protonated methanol, CH3OH2 positive. It is not neutral methanol until a separate deprotonation occurs.

(c)

Oxygen now has three bonds, one lone pair and charge +1; the carbon has four bonds and is neutral. Total charge remains +1.