Combining the Patterns of Arrow Pushing — Question 6

Section 6-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 1341–1342

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Combine delocalization analysis with alternative bond formation

Bromide can formally bond at either electron-deficient end of this allylic system. Use resonance analysis to identify the two connectivities; do not predict a product ratio.

Delocalized allylic cation contributor
  1. Draw the second cation contributor by moving the pi pair.

  2. Draw the two possible neutral bromide-capture products.

  3. Does drawing two resonance contributors add an extra elementary reaction step before capture?

Question 6 - Solution

Combine delocalization analysis with alternative bond formation

Terminal capture
Other allylic-site capture

(a)

Move the pi pair toward the terminal cation to obtain CH3–CH positive–CH=CH2. No atom changes neighbors.

(b)

Capture gives CH3–CH=CH–CH2Br or CH3–CH(Br)–CH=CH2. These differ in bromine attachment and double-bond location.

(c)

No. The contributors describe one delocalized intermediate. Bond formation is a reaction event; resonance drawings are not separate interconverting intermediates.