Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Avoid inferring the pathway solely from the net product
Only the two connectivities are known. No kinetic, stereochemical, solvent or reagent information has been supplied.
| Substrate |
| Observed alcohol connectivity |
What reaction class is consistent with the replacement?
Does this prove a concerted or a carbocation-mediated pathway?
Name two useful kinds of additional evidence.
Question 5 - Solution
Avoid inferring the pathway solely from the net product
| Substrate |
| Observed alcohol connectivity |
(a)
The change is consistent with nucleophilic substitution of Br by an oxygen-containing group.
(b)
No. Different mechanisms can produce this same connectivity. The net equation omits the order of bond changes.
(c)
Rate dependence on substrate and nucleophile, stereochemical outcomes, rearranged products and solvent effects can help distinguish pathways. No single missing datum should be silently assumed.