Alkyl Halides — Question 8

Section 7-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 1445–1446

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Explain why the most polar bond need not leave fastest

For ordinary nucleophilic substitution of comparable alkyl halides, iodide is generally a much better leaving group than fluoride.

Compare the same methyl skeleton
Compare
  1. Would electronegativity alone predict this trend correctly?

  2. Name two factors relevant to departure.

  3. Why is C–F polarization insufficient evidence for fast substitution?

Question 8 - Solution

Explain why the most polar bond need not leave fastest

Compare the same methyl skeleton
Compare

(a)

No. Strong bond polarization is not the same as easy bond cleavage.

(b)

The strong C–F bond resists cleavage; iodide is larger, more polarizable and a weaker base than fluoride. Solvation and the full activation barrier also matter.

(c)

A polar bond can still be strong and kinetically resistant. Reactivity must be judged from the reaction barrier, not a partial-charge label alone.