Possible Mechanisms for Substitution Reactions — Question 5

Section 7-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 1459–1460

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Reject a five-complete-bond carbon intermediate

A student calls this species an isolable SN2 intermediate.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Count the electrons in the five proposed bonds.

  2. Why is the structure inappropriate for ordinary second-row carbon?

  3. How should the SN2 transition state be represented?

Question 5 - Solution

Reject a five-complete-bond carbon intermediate

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Five complete two-electron bonds place ten bonding electrons around carbon.

(b)

This violates the ordinary octet description and misrepresents SN2 as a two-step process with a stable pentacoordinate species.

(c)

Use partial forming and breaking bonds in a bracketed transition state with a double-dagger symbol. It is a barrier geometry, not an isolable intermediate.