Possible Mechanisms for Substitution Reactions — Question 10

Section 7-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 1469–1470

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Identify the experiment that tests the missing hypothesis

Candidate A is direct SN2 substitution; candidate B is rate-limiting ionization followed by capture. Only product connectivity has been measured.

Same product from two candidate routes
  1. Design a kinetic comparison.

  2. Design a stereochemical comparison.

  3. Explain why agreement between independent evidence is useful.

Question 10 - Solution

Identify the experiment that tests the missing hypothesis

Same product from two candidate routes

(a)

Measure initial rates at several nucleophile concentrations while holding substrate, solvent, temperature and relevant ionic strength fixed.

(b)

Use a configurationally characterized substrate and determine product configuration or enantiomeric composition, accounting for changed CIP priorities.

(c)

Rate dependence and stereochemical outcome test different consequences of a pathway. Consistent evidence is stronger than guessing a mechanism from the product alone.