The SN1 Mechanism — Question 4

Section 7-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 1497–1498

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Recognize resonance stabilization at an allylic cation

These are resonance contributors of one allylic carbocation, not two equilibrating constitutional isomers.

One contributor
Another contributor
  1. What electron pair moves between contributors?

  2. Do any nuclei migrate?

  3. Why can an allylic halide depart more readily than a comparable simple primary halide?

Question 4 - Solution

Recognize resonance stabilization at an allylic cation

One contributor
Another contributor

(a)

The pi pair shifts toward the adjacent positively charged carbon, relocating the formal positive charge to the other terminal carbon.

(b)

No. The atomic connectivity and positions are unchanged; only the electron assignment differs.

(c)

The positive charge can be delocalized over the allylic framework. A primary label alone therefore does not describe the full stability of the ionization product.