The SN1 Mechanism — Question 10

Section 7-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 1509–1510

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Separate SN1 plausibility from exclusive substitution yield

The substrate is warmed in an ionizing protic solvent with a weak neutral nucleophile.

Tertiary substrate
  1. Why is a carbocation pathway plausible?

  2. What competing reaction can share the same cation?

  3. What evidence is needed before claiming quantitative alcohol formation?

Question 10 - Solution

Separate SN1 plausibility from exclusive substitution yield

Tertiary substrate

(a)

Departure can produce a tertiary carbocation, stabilized by its alkyl groups, in a medium suited to ionization.

(b)

E1 elimination can compete: loss of a beta proton from the cation creates an alkene.

(c)

Measure the product distribution and conversion. Conditions favorable for SN1 do not establish that every cation is trapped as an alcohol.