Determining Which Mechanism Predominates — Question 7

Section 7-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 1563–1564

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Explain why a benzylic substrate can support either route

Compare A: soluble anionic nucleophile in a polar aprotic solvent; B: ionizing protic medium with only weak neutral donor.

Benzyl bromide
  1. Why is SN2 plausible in A?

  2. Why is SN1 plausible in B?

  3. What observation would help distinguish the actual routes?

Question 7 - Solution

Explain why a benzylic substrate can support either route

Benzyl bromide

(a)

The accessible benzylic CH2 permits direct attack, assisted by the neighboring pi system. A strong nucleophile can favor SN2.

(b)

Ionization gives a resonance-stabilized benzyl cation, making a stepwise pathway plausible in an ionizing medium.

(c)

Controlled rate dependence on added nucleophile can help. Benzyl bromide is not chiral at CH2, so racemization at that carbon cannot be used as the discriminator.