Determining Which Mechanism Predominates — Question 10

Section 7-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 1569–1570

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Reconcile conflicting kinetic and stereochemical evidence

The substrate can form a stabilized carbocation, and donor addition does not alter the medium. Only substitution products are counted.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which limiting mechanism fits the kinetic observation?

  2. Must SN1 be rejected because the product is not exactly racemic?

  3. Why would pure ideal SN2 be an incomplete account?

Question 10 - Solution

Reconcile conflicting kinetic and stereochemical evidence

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Rate-limiting ionization followed by rapid capture, the limiting SN1 model, is consistent with donor-independent rate.

(b)

No. An ion pair can shield one face and favor inversion. The given product has 44 percent enantiomeric excess toward inversion.

(c)

Ideal SN2 would be stereospecific and normally depend on nucleophile concentration. The combined evidence favors an ionization/capture account, subject to the stated assumptions.