Substitution vs. Elimination: Identifying the Reagent — Question 1

Section 8-12 · Organic Chemistry pages 1811–1812

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Distinguish a neutral alcohol from its conjugate base

Compare the donor atoms before selecting a mechanism.

Methanol
Methoxide
  1. Give the oxygen charge and lone-pair count in each species.

  2. Which is the stronger base?

  3. Why does the word oxygen reagent fail to specify a mechanism?

Question 1 - Solution

Distinguish a neutral alcohol from its conjugate base

Methanol
Methoxide

(a)

Methanol O has charge zero and two lone pairs; methoxide O has charge -1 and three lone pairs.

(b)

Methoxide is the stronger base and is also an effective nucleophile. Neutral methanol is much less basic.

(c)

Charge, steric access, substrate and solvent matter. Methanol can trap an accessible carbocation; methoxide can support SN2 or E2 depending on the substrate.