Substitution vs. Elimination: Identifying the Reagent — Question 3

Section 8-12 · Organic Chemistry pages 1815–1816

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Use conjugate-acid data without confusing two kinds of reactivity

Use the supplied approximate aqueous values: pKaK_a(EtSH) = 10.5 and pKaK_a(EtOH) = 16.0.

Ethanethiolate
Ethoxide
  1. Rank the two bases.

  2. Estimate the equilibrium constant for EtO negative + EtSH to EtOH + EtS negative.

  3. Does weaker basicity force thiolate to be a poor carbon nucleophile?

Question 3 - Solution

Use conjugate-acid data without confusing two kinds of reactivity

Ethanethiolate
Ethoxide

(a)

Ethoxide is the stronger base because its conjugate acid has the higher pKaK_a.

(b)

K≈1016.0−10.5=3.2×105K\approx10^{16.0-10.5}=3.2\times10^5 for the stated proton transfer. These values belong to the supplied aqueous comparison.

(c)

No. Thiolate can be a highly effective nucleophile at an accessible saturated carbon. Basicity concerns proton-transfer equilibrium; nucleophilicity concerns a reaction rate.