Substitution vs. Elimination: Identifying the Reagent — Question 9

Section 8-12 · Organic Chemistry pages 1827–1828

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Read a solvent-dependent nucleophilicity experiment

Each row compares matched substrate concentration, anion concentration and temperature. Values are hypothetical; comparisons between solvents include solvent effects.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Rank the nucleophiles within each solvent.

  2. Compute the faster/slower ratio in each row.

  3. Can this table establish a universal basicity order?

Question 9 - Solution

Read a solvent-dependent nucleophilicity experiment

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Iodide is faster in the protic medium; fluoride is faster in the aprotic medium.

(b)

The ratios are 20 in the protic row and 5 in the aprotic row.

(c)

No. These are kinetic SN2 data under specified solvation conditions. They neither supply acid-base equilibrium constants nor justify a solvent-independent nucleophilicity ranking.