Substitution vs. Elimination: Identifying the Mechanism(s) — Question 1

Section 8-13 · Organic Chemistry pages 1831–1832

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Apply the beta-carbon requirement before choosing a strong-base mechanism

Consider the ordinary SN1, SN2, E1 and E2 possibilities in a suitable substitution medium.

Methyl iodide
Ethoxide
  1. Which pathway is favored?

  2. Which two elimination pathways lack a required structural feature?

  3. Why is ordinary SN1 also unfavorable?

Question 1 - Solution

Apply the beta-carbon requirement before choosing a strong-base mechanism

Methyl iodide
Ethoxide

(a)

SN2 is favored: methyl carbon is accessible to backside attack by ethoxide.

(b)

E1 and E2 cannot produce an ordinary alkene because there is no beta carbon.

(c)

Ionization would create an unstabilized methyl carbocation. Strong base does not override the structural exclusions.