Substitution vs. Elimination: Identifying the Mechanism(s) — Question 3

Section 8-13 · Organic Chemistry pages 1835–1836

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Keep two plausible bimolecular branches in a secondary system

No product ratio or temperature is specified.

2-Bromobutane
Ethoxide
  1. Which two mechanisms should remain in the analysis?

  2. Explain why each is plausible.

  3. What evidence is needed to assign the dominant branch quantitatively?

Question 3 - Solution

Keep two plausible bimolecular branches in a secondary system

2-Bromobutane
Ethoxide

(a)

SN2 and E2 are both plausible.

(b)

Ethoxide can attack a secondary carbon or remove a beta proton. Secondary crowding impedes substitution but does not forbid it; beta hydrogens permit elimination.

(c)

Product analysis under specified solvent, concentration and temperature is needed. The reagent name alone cannot establish an exact ratio.